I have never left the KP trade bandwagon, he is fools gold. The team plays better when he does not play, at least Luka does anyone because he is able to play freel
We will never be a contender with him as the 2nd option on this team.
His durability and mentality is just not what you want from a guy getting paid like a superstar. The sooner the Mavericks figure this out the better.
Also, Luka needs traditional pieces, screen setters and finishers around the basket type skillsets from his bigs. KP is not consistent enough to provide that.
(01-30-2022, 10:17 AM)ThisIStheYear Wrote: [ -> ]He seems like kind of an injury risk now that he’s in his 30s. He’s missed a lot of games the last couple of years. I’d say he’s a player in decline. Brunson is the better, more versatile player, now and going forward.
Brunson is for Collins. KP is for CJ.
I think KP is a better player than McCollum just in terms of impact, but if we only get 50 games a year from KP I'd rather have McCollum.
McCollum isn't a slouch either. He is one of the best mid range shooters of the last 5 years, and he's averaged nearly 5 assists a game in that same span. Brunson is for sure the more attractive piece, but I think Collins is near Brunson's territory there anyways.
(01-30-2022, 11:33 AM)SleepingHero Wrote: [ -> ]Brunson is for Collins. KP is for CJ.
I think KP is a better player than McCollum just in terms of impact, but if we only get 50 games a year from KP I'd rather have McCollum.
McCollum isn't a slouch either. He is one of the best mid range shooters of the last 5 years, and he's averaged nearly 5 assists a game in that same span. Brunson is for sure the more attractive piece, but I think Collins is near Brunson's territory there anyways.
If we are talking major blow-up again, I´d probably prefer
Porzingis/Levert to Sacramento
Barnes/THJ to Indiana
Turner/Hield to Dallas
(01-30-2022, 12:08 PM)Mavs2021 Wrote: [ -> ]If we are talking major blow-up again, I´d probably prefer
Porzingis/Levert to Sacramento
Barnes/THJ to Indiana
Turner/Hield to Dallas
Ah yes I too would be interested in seeing a good Sacramento team again but not at the expense of the Mavs.
(01-30-2022, 11:33 AM)SleepingHero Wrote: [ -> ]Brunson is for Collins. KP is for CJ.
I think KP is a better player than McCollum just in terms of impact, but if we only get 50 games a year from KP I'd rather have McCollum.
McCollum isn't a slouch either. He is one of the best mid range shooters of the last 5 years, and he's averaged nearly 5 assists a game in that same span. Brunson is for sure the more attractive piece, but I think Collins is near Brunson's territory there anyways.
I’d be just fine with a package that brings back Collins. He has size and athleticism and usually has excellent shooting splits from the three, the two, and the line (I haven’t checked this year though). Somehow, he seems underutilized in Atlanta, though I think he could be an all star in Dallas. But that part of this trade idea seems like a complicated pipe dream. My plan would be more like pay Brunson his $20 million per year and look for a way to dump a meaningful portion of Zinger’s salary. I admit that’s not as fun though.
I voted "HOLD ON TO HIM" today.
This thread is going to be locked and buried.
As expected, KP is catching a lot of grief now that he's gone. Some of that is warranted and some of it is not. Yes, he wanted out of New York. No, he didn't ask for the Mavs to trade for him. Yes, he signed the contract. The injuries weren't his fault and surely frustrated him much more than it ever frustrated anyone else. He was "the guy" in New York and Dallas gave him a contract to be "the guy", at least in tandem, here. The fit never worked with Luka, nor Carlisle. He bares some responsibility in that but so do the Mavs for trading for him before they even knew what they had with their drafted superstar. Carlisle and traded players, much like draft picks, are often a coinflip. There were moments tantalizing greatness and moments that left us scratching our heads. Throughout it all, he was a class act and professional with the media and by all accounts, was a hard worked and good teammate (DFS approved). Before we bury him for the injuries and on-the-court shortcomings, I think we should try to put ourselves in his shoes. It can't have been easy to be relegated to the role he ended up with towards the end of Carlisle's tenure. I don't think he handled the on court frustrations perfectly, but no one is perfect and things could have been a lot worse.
While the relationship is a mess and I was never his biggest fan as a player, I am a fan of the person. I appreciate KP and hope you find health and success on the court and beyond.
KP and Luka were not a good match together on the floor. We all know they are not the best defenders so it's hard to have both on the floor. But even offensively, it looked like their games and skillsets did not compliment each other. The Two Man Game never worked out because Luka isn't really a blow-by-the-defender type of guard to create the overall space that KP needs and KP was a decent but not great shooter from deep. What made the Two Man Game work so well with Dirk/Jet and even Dirk/JJB was because of the space that the players could create, either with the defense respecting Dirk/Jet's shooting ability or JJB's quickness and slashing ability.
Defenses know that when they see KP setting a screen for Luka, they will need to switch and take their chances with Luka vs. a big man or KP vs. a smaller defender. Or be aggressive guarding Luka with both defenders and leave KP wide open for a long three that he would often settle for. If they switched and KP had a smaller defender, he struggled to consistently win those matchups.
Luka is better off with a rim-running big man and/or a true sharpshooter. And I think KP will be better with a PG with traditional size who is quick and can get to the rim.
When do we find out if the trade is complete? I.e. he didn't flunk the physical?