2021-2022 ROSTER TALK: [ARCHIVED]

[mvossman]

So, I finally read the Iztok article. His criteria for the 3 spot as it pertains to THJ is one that basically says he scores more ppg than the 4 and 5 spots. He scores some 2’s (at least 50% assisted), but mostly 3’s (at least 80% assisted), doesn’t assist others significantly, doesn’t handle the ball well outside 1-2 dribbles (and those dribbles are mostly to side-step a defender). The 4 and 5’s have those same qualities, as well as being play finishers (a part of the listed 3 qualities for whatever reason).

Side note: Like RC, Iztok gave lip service to defense in the article but I never saw evidence of using it in any of the categories he put players in. In what world is Dillon Brooks the same category as THJ. I mean, offensively I want Brooks more than THJ, then defensively they are worlds apart! Defense is just as (if not more) important as offense in the playoffs.

I think Iztok make it clear he was focusing on offense for that article.  In that thread I made the argument that in order for the 4 and 5 to be useful playoff pieces, they need to add defense to the equation (perimeter defense for the 4 and rim protection for the 5) where it is gravy for the other spots.

Brooks is a better defender than THJ, but I don't really know why you would prefer him offensively to Timmy?  I believe you referred to THJ as an inefficient chucker, but Brooks is way less efficient.  He has never had a True shooting much north of 50%.

I agree defense is important, especially at the team level, but when evaluating individual players, offense is the bigger driver.  There is a much bigger difference between a good offensive player and a bad offensive player than there is on the defensive end.