Which player would you rather have?

[ItsGoTime]

Do we need a "who loves Maxi the most?" thread?

It's funny cause I think they take that statement as if I'm saying I love him more than anyone, which is not what I said.

You said you love him as much as anyone - not true if you'd trade him for Gordon.

I would include Maxi in a trade for Turner, because Turner is a better version of Maxi, bringing much the same strengths. The Wurzburg + chemistry intangibles would make it hurt, but you have to give to get.

Turner is not a star or superstar or even all-star snub, that makes my point. When did I say I'd trade Gordon for Kleber? I remember saying I thought it was a no brainer until I looked at the numbers, I then didn't know what I thought and put up the poll.