MavsBoard
2020-2021 ROSTER TALK: Archived - Printable Version

+- MavsBoard (https://www.mavsboard.com)
+-- Forum: Boards (https://www.mavsboard.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Dallas Mavericks and the NBA (https://www.mavsboard.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Thread: 2020-2021 ROSTER TALK: Archived (/showthread.php?tid=682)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456 457 458 459 460 461 462 463 464 465 466 467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 475 476 477 478 479 480


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - StepBackJay - 04-01-2021

https://www.theringer.com/nba/2021/3/22/22343534/john-collins-atlanta-hawks-trade-deadline

So just revisiting this again. Hawks wanted a "high level" first round pick and/or young player and obviously didn't get that. Doesn't mean they won't get a first round pick or young player this summer. They said they intend to match all RFA offers which I believe. I don't think Mavs will make an RFA max offer and just try to call the Hawks' bluff. The Hawks aren't dumb they would match vs losing an asset for nothing.

Mavs do not have a first round pick but doesn't mean they couldn't get one. I think the Brogdan deal isn't a bad comp. Pacers gave up a first round pick and two seconds plus a 20 mil/yr contract in that S&T deal. Mavs have Brunson plus a few young players and I think Maxi could fetch a pick. At any rate I do expect Mavs to try to make a Collins deal happen. I bet this is their plan A. Casualties could include some combination of anyone outside of Luka, KP and I think DFS is a guy they want to hold onto.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $25.7M - $37.3M in capspace this summer - DanSchwartzgan - 04-01-2021

(03-31-2021, 02:39 PM)omahen Wrote: Luka, McConell,      Terry
JRich, THJ,            Green
OPJ, DFS,              Hinton
Maxi,                     Bey
KP, Theis,              WCS (or let him walk and sign someone else)

I think we get very, very tough defensively with TJ and Theis. We get secondary playmaking with TJ. We get shooting with OPJ. Not flashy but it might work very well.

FIFY.  This is the antithesis of 3 stars.  It is pretty close to 9 starters and I like it.  We can quibble over the who and the how, but this seems a much easier path than the path to Collins or any other near-max guy (Holiday?).  This kind of thing, done over or under the cap, is more interesting to discuss than letting go of everyone and hope Mr. Free Agent picks us.   This is how Indy has operated in recent years.  Instead of waiting around for the pipe dreams, they just go get their guys and call it a day. 

I'll be surprised if we can trade Powell in a way that helps us, so I'll probably be leaving that out of my proposals.  However, I am optimistic we might be able to use Redick as outgoing in some deal.  Time will tell.  Obviously, the big question is THJ.  Do we keep him.  Do we S&T him or do we let him walk and operate under the cap.  Speaking of names:  

Theis is genius.  As a younger alternative, I wonder what it will take to snatch the other Collins from Portland.  Thaddeus Young was a trade deadline darling and we got a mention that we were involved with Nance just to throw out a couple more names.  The key is being big enough to not get creamed against bigger teams and quick enough to not get run off the court when teams go small (like that would ever happen Smile ).  It really helps if the guy in this slot can hit an occasional three.  I think you will always have to carry an extra center with KP on the team, so, I suspect there will always be at least one other playable big in addition to the spot Theis is filling (could be Powell or WCS)

I like OPJ.  I need to spend some time looking for alternatives.  Rudy Gay would help the bench scoring for a year or two while you wait for Green and Bey to grow up.  He probably comes a good bit cheaper than OPJ    

McConnell is the one I'm a little meh on.  I like Monk as an alternative.  He has a $13mm hold on a team with three good guards already in Ball, Rozier and Graham.  They need a big (to me that is where Collins should go) and that cap hold is in the way.  He isn't your dad's Buick any more (meaning he isn't the Monk of a couple of years ago).  He can create a little and is really good at hitting 3's these days.  He's a positive on-court despite having really good replacements take his place when he isn't in.  There are other guys who are older and more expensive who might fill this bench scorer role.  Mainly, I'd like to have one more mix and match guy to go with Brunson and JRich (assuming he stays) and I'd like to be able to play any two without Luka and any two with Luka.  

I've spent a lot of time saying I think THJ should be retained and that he's too valuable to risk on RFA dreams.  But, he's a pretty one dimensional guy who eats a lot of cap.  There are other alternatives to play his "bench scorer" role and you might be able to get two guys for similar money.  It would be nice to upgrade a starter, but there aren't a ton of shots available to attract someone like that.  There are certainly some opportunities to add to a very thin bench (basically THJ and Brunson right now).  As we've seen with Kemba, it doesn't always pay to chase the big name guy.  I think we would be much improved if we simply added a few more Maxi/Brunson level players and could field nine starter level guys instead of the current seven.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - StepBackJay - 04-01-2021

A couple issues Dan w/this approach:

1. The middle class of guys who are bubble starters are also hard to get. You may want Ibaka or Harrell but you wind up with WCS and Burke. You might want Danny Green but you get Delon Wright. That being said this is for sure the Mavs backup plan because what else are they going to do? They have 5 of their top 7 players under contract and 25-37 or whatever million dollars in cap space so I think they put together a team even if they strike out on their "big fish" (which evidently is Collins).

2. It's a stars league and so far the teams with the best ones win. With Collins I think he is the best option in terms of asset management, not only bc he is a good player but if he doesn't fit I believe he can get you a player of similar caliber. You can always find role players but if you want a star or guy with star potential it's a lot easier if you have a player of your own that the other team wants. I haven't been a fan of plan powder but I understand the 3-star plan at least.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - HAguiar95 - 04-01-2021

If we want to be aggressive in Free Agency, there are a couple of options:

Guard (PG/SG): Under contract = Doncic, Brunson, Burke, Terry

We are pretty good here with Doncic starting and JB backing him up. Heat have a bunch of guys they need to pay (Dragic, Nunn, Robinson, Oladipo) so if we need to involve JB in a trade for a starter caliber player, we might scoop Dragic or Nunn for maybe 12-15M.

Wing (SG/SF/PF): Under contract = DFS, Green

I really don't see a viable option here on the market, so my preference is to keep both J-Rich and THJ. I'll assume both go in the range of 15-18M. Other guys in this range is Robinson (again, another MIA player) and Oubre. Josh Hart (probably gets 12-15M) is another RFA name to keep an eye, since NOP has to deal with Lonzo (probably will be overpaid by someone, I predict 20-23M). I'm scared of giving OPJ money (15M+) because of his injuries, but probably a last resort since we have our rookie to play in case of emergency (I'm sure RC would LOVE that).


Big (PF/C): Under contract = KP, Maxi, Powell, WCS (TO)

To me Collins is a pipe dream and very far from reality and Markkanen overlaps with KP in skillset. What I'd like to see here is a backup signed for the MLE money (9-12M) to compete with DP for the PF/C minutes (don't like what WCS has shown so far). Lots of options with Olynyk and Theis as my favorites (Portis and Birch on my watchlist too). Holmes feels like starter money (15-18M) and I'm not sure he actually starts here.

Start the season with the rotation of:

Guards: Doncic (35)/Brunson (25)/Burke (5)
Wings: Richardson (30)/Hardaway (30)/Finney-Smith (30)/Green (10)
Bigs: Porzingis (30)/Kleber (25)/ Theis (20)

Kind of the same roster we already have with another backup big (marginal improvement). Not fantastic, but due to our current situation I see no way we get anything better on FA. Trade market will be our best chance to actually improve the roster with starter level players with DP + Burke (14.2M) as our salary fillers and our role players/picks as the prize (we know Mavs already tried moving DFS and Kleber).


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $25.7M - $37.3M in capspace this summer - cow - 04-01-2021

(04-01-2021, 04:14 PM)mvossman Wrote: Based on your posts, I am guessing you are going to hate this, but I kind of like the idea of offering him an extension.  I think the max we can offer him is something like 13?  I think he has had a down year shooting, and had some lingering struggles with the whole Covid thing.  He has been disappointing, but an extension at that price would be buying low.

Hate is probably too strong of a word.  Buy low might be too strong of a descriptor for that type of contract.  A contract in that range might just be what he is worth, the guy is 28 and a six year veteran.  His three point shooting will probably bounce back as these seems like a down year but his 2PT and FT % should probably return to the norm as well.  He shows defensive flashes and is decent enough with the ball against average defenders to get shots up.  While I don't really want to be the team that pays him, he just needs to be easily moveable and based around all the tea leaves we saw coming into the TDL, he wasn't a very desirable expiring.  Granted we are only privy to NBA reporting and NBA twitter but I don't remember any grumblings about him.  

I guess the question I keep asking is, "has he made the team any better this year"?


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $25.7M - $37.3M in capspace this summer - mvossman - 04-01-2021

(04-01-2021, 08:24 PM)cow Wrote: Hate is probably too strong of a word.  Buy low might be too strong of a descriptor for that type of contract.  A contract in that range might just be what he is worth, the guy is 28 and a six year veteran.  His three point shooting will probably bounce back as these seems like a down year but his 2PT and FT % should probably return to the norm as well.  He shows defensive flashes and is decent enough with the ball against average defenders to get shots up.  While I don't really want to be the team that pays him, he just needs to be easily moveable and based around all the tea leaves we saw coming into the TDL, he wasn't a very desirable expiring.  Granted we are only privy to NBA reporting and NBA twitter but I don't remember any grumblings about him.  

I guess the question I keep asking is, "has he made the team any better this year"?

To me, the real question is, what is the likelihood of him making the team better in the future.  I think we are seeing his floor right now  for various reasons (luck, Covid, new team, etc).  He is not what we are looking for as a secondary creator and he is not a lock down defender.  He is a guy that can provide some versatility on offense (not great but better than DFS or Maxi) and he is currently the only quality defender we have that can handle 1s (as well as wings on switches).  He is a proven legit starter on quality teams, which is something we are in short supply of.  He is prolly worth roughly 15 a year, so at 13 a year he is a legit asset (due to the scarcity of quality starters).  A big part of this is that I think we are better off operating over the cap, in which case we are better off re-signing him and THJ.  I think there are limited/unlikely scenarios where operating under the cap will actually improve the team we currently have.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - Kammrath - 04-01-2021

(04-01-2021, 05:57 PM)StepBackJay Wrote: Mavs do not have a first round pick but doesn't mean they couldn't get one. I think the Brogdan deal isn't a bad comp. Pacers gave up a first round pick and two seconds plus a 20 mil/yr contract in that S&T deal. Mavs have Brunson plus a few young players and I think Maxi could fetch a pick. At any rate I do expect Mavs to try to make a Collins deal happen. I bet this is their plan A.


I hope this is their plan A, it would definitely be mine. A 23 year old budding star? Got to take your shot IMO. 

Once the draft passes and the Knicks get the 2021 pick, don't the Mavs then acquire the ability to trade a pick again pretty easy?

I am also 100% with you that getting JC puts the Mavs in a MUCH better asset situation moving forward. I think Luka and maturity will make JC of this summer nothing compared to what he would be worth in another summer or two.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - cow - 04-02-2021

(04-01-2021, 08:56 PM)Kammrath Wrote: Once the draft passes and the Knicks get the 2021 pick, don't the Mavs then acquire the ability to trade a pick again pretty easy?

2021 is unprotected.  2023 is top 10 protected through 2025.  Without removing the protections, I believe the earliest FRP the Mavs can trade is 2027.  If they removed the protections (don't do this), that would bump the pick to 2025.  I would think for a S&T, the other team is going to want that pick to come before 2027 and maybe before 2025.  You'd probably need to figure out a way to get a FRP from someone else which means sending out Jalen or Maxi.  I guess you could add KP to that list of names but that really starts to complicate things.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $25.7M - $37.3M in capspace this summer - cow - 04-02-2021

(04-01-2021, 08:47 PM)mvossman Wrote: To me, the real question is, what is the likelihood of him making the team better in the future.  I think we are seeing his floor right now  for various reasons (luck, Covid, new team, etc).  He is not what we are looking for as a secondary creator and he is not a lock down defender.  He is a guy that can provide some versatility on offense (not great but better than DFS or Maxi) and he is currently the only quality defender we have that can handle 1s (as well as wings on switches).  He is a proven legit starter on quality teams, which is something we are in short supply of.  He is prolly worth roughly 15 a year, so at 13 a year he is a legit asset (due to the scarcity of quality starters).  A big part of this is that I think we are better off operating over the cap, in which case we are better off re-signing him and THJ.  I think there are limited/unlikely scenarios where operating under the cap will actually improve the team we currently have.

I guess I just don't agree with the assessment that this is his floor.  And if he is merely okay on both sides of the floor, I'm not sure getting off a long term deal at around 15m per year (factoring in raises)  would be easy.  In order, my hopes for him this offseason:

1.  Opts in
2.  Opts out and tests the market and finds a new time.
3.  Opts out and we resign him after exhausting all other options.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - Mavs2021 - 04-02-2021

(04-02-2021, 04:02 AM)cow Wrote: 2021 is unprotected.  2023 is top 10 protected through 2025.  Without removing the protections, I believe the earliest FRP the Mavs can trade is 2027.  If they removed the protections (don't do this), that would bump the pick to 2025.  I would think for a S&T, the other team is going to want that pick to come before 2027 and maybe before 2025.  You'd probably need to figure out a way to get a FRP from someone else which means sending out Jalen or Maxi.  I guess you could add KP to that list of names but that really starts to complicate things.

Since all picks recently traded go up to 2027, so I assume you can include picks until 2028 after the next draft. I think it won´t take a lot of convincing to offer the Knicks a swap of 2023 top 10 protected for 2022 unprotected.

In that case we certainly have the assets to pull off trades for Collins and Lavine, but then we are truly empty with

Doncic/Brunson
Lavine/Richardson
DFS/X
Collins/Bey
Porzingis/X


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - StepBackJay - 04-02-2021

(04-01-2021, 08:56 PM)Kammrath Wrote: I hope this is their plan A, it would definitely be mine. A 23 year old budding star? Got to take your shot IMO. 

Once the draft passes and the Knicks get the 2021 pick, don't the Mavs then acquire the ability to trade a pick again pretty easy?

I am also 100% with you that getting JC puts the Mavs in a MUCH better asset situation moving forward. I think Luka and maturity will make JC of this summer nothing compared to what he would be worth in another summer or two.

Ya so I have come around on this idea. I do believe that the Mavs will not be able to just steal Collins away with a max offer. I previously thought Collins was a low % shot if Mavs' plan is just a big offer sheet. Mavs were willing to trade Maxi at the TDL which shows me they are ready to be aggressive in getting Collins. 

The asking price was a first round pick and/or young player which is not a terrible asking price given that usually is the ceiling of what a team can actually get. We also did not see any sort of consensus that the Hawks were not interested in trading Collins at all, just that it was unlikely he would be moved at the TDL.

So with that I do think Mavs have enough pieces to get an offer out to the Hawks that they would accept. To me the main risk is just other bidders coming in that might have a better offer.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - Branduil - 04-02-2021

(04-02-2021, 04:02 AM)cow Wrote: 2021 is unprotected.  2023 is top 10 protected through 2025.  Without removing the protections, I believe the earliest FRP the Mavs can trade is 2027.  If they removed the protections (don't do this), that would bump the pick to 2025.  I would think for a S&T, the other team is going to want that pick to come before 2027 and maybe before 2025.  You'd probably need to figure out a way to get a FRP from someone else which means sending out Jalen or Maxi.  I guess you could add KP to that list of names but that really starts to complicate things.
Rather than complicate things, I think trading KP makes things simpler in the sense that I don't think the Mavs can get the assets to trade for Collins otherwise. The complication is that I don't think Atlanta would want KP so things would have to be routed through a third team.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - StepBackJay - 04-02-2021

(04-02-2021, 04:02 AM)cow Wrote: 2021 is unprotected.  2023 is top 10 protected through 2025.  Without removing the protections, I believe the earliest FRP the Mavs can trade is 2027.  If they removed the protections (don't do this), that would bump the pick to 2025.  I would think for a S&T, the other team is going to want that pick to come before 2027 and maybe before 2025.  You'd probably need to figure out a way to get a FRP from someone else which means sending out Jalen or Maxi.  I guess you could add KP to that list of names but that really starts to complicate things.

Also a thing we need to understand is that future firsts are first and foremost a store of value, like Bitcoin or currency. So ya a pick way into the future seems less valuable than one in the near-term but it's not always the case. For one, a future pick is one that takes up no salary or roster spots. Some teams have too many young players as it is. They don't need more guys taking up minutes, salary and roster spots. 

Further, future picks add more risk to the team trading them away because so much can change during that time. For the Mavs if they had a pick next year you can predict with a fair degree of access where that pick will be. For a future pick you don't know where it will land and you can up the value by removing protections.

All that being said I don't know if the Mavs will trade a future first or not. My guess is that they would move around some of their roster to get a pick or two that then can get passed to a team like Atlanta if they go big on Collins.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - StepBackJay - 04-02-2021

(04-02-2021, 06:13 AM)Mavs2021 Wrote: Since all picks recently traded go up to 2027, so I assume you can include picks until 2028 after the next draft. I think it won´t take a lot of convincing to offer the Knicks a swap of 2023 top 10 protected for 2022 unprotected.

In that case we certainly have the assets to pull off trades for Collins and Lavine, but then we are truly empty with

Doncic/Brunson
Lavine/Richardson
DFS/X
Collins/Bey
Porzingis/X

The window for a LaVine trade just got slammed shut with the big Vuc trade. I think your next opportunity would be if/when he hits free agency.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - khaled1987 - 04-02-2021

(04-02-2021, 06:13 AM)Mavs2021 Wrote: Since all picks recently traded go up to 2027, so I assume you can include picks until 2028 after the next draft. I think it won´t take a lot of convincing to offer the Knicks a swap of 2023 top 10 protected for 2022 unprotected.

In that case we certainly have the assets to pull off trades for Collins and Lavine, but then we are truly empty with

Doncic/Brunson
Lavine/Richardson
DFS/X
Collins/Bey
Porzingis/X

You can trade picks up to 7 years, so 2028 is the last pick you can trade.
This means we have 2025th and 2027th picks if we remove protection from all picks (2023, 2025 & 2027th)  
That will be dangerous since if this trades doesn't work, means we will be potentially trading 2 picks after Luka leaves .
And I think it will be impossible to trade 2022 for 2023 with Knicks,  because that mean A-they will need to cash on their asset soon, takes flexibility from them and B-they will help us to get assets for trades to improve our team, which means worse pick for them.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - Branduil - 04-02-2021

I keep going back to OKC as potential destination for KP in a trade. Mainly because they have a mountain of picks and the cap space next offseason to just absorb KP outright(and then some).

So if the Mavs could convince Collins to sign with us, they could do something like trading KP and Powell to OKC, who then sends 1 first back to us and Bazley and 2 firsts to Atlanta, and Atlanta sends Collins.

With this trade, if JRich opted out then the Mavs would end up with something close to $45 million in cap space in addition to Collins. That's more than enough to re-sign THJ and also pursue other targets.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - khaled1987 - 04-02-2021

(04-02-2021, 08:44 AM)Branduil Wrote: I keep going back to OKC as potential destination for KP in a trade. Mainly because they have a mountain of picks and the cap space next offseason to just absorb KP outright(and then some).

So if the Mavs could convince Collins to sign with us, they could do something like trading KP and Powell to OKC, who then sends 1 first back to us and Bazley and 2 firsts to Atlanta, and Atlanta sends Collins.

With this trade, if JRich opted out then the Mavs would end up with something close to $45 million in cap space in addition to Collins. That's more than enough to re-sign THJ and also pursue other targets.

This makes me think, OKC will most likely be the biggest player in RFA, not the Mavs.
Cap space, nothing to lose if other team matches , tons of assets to work with teams for S&T.
Seems to me they will be better Signing/trading for Collins rather than going for KP.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - DanSchwartzgan - 04-02-2021

(04-01-2021, 07:22 PM)StepBackJay Wrote: A couple issues Dan w/this approach:

1. The middle class of guys who are bubble starters are also hard to get. You may want Ibaka or Harrell but you wind up with WCS and Burke. You might want Danny Green but you get Delon Wright. That being said this is for sure the Mavs backup plan because what else are they going to do? They have 5 of their top 7 players under contract and 25-37 or whatever million dollars in cap space so I think they put together a team even if they strike out on their "big fish" (which evidently is Collins).

I don't think the issue is how hard it is to get the middle class.  I think the issue is the middle class is always Plan B while we chase the bigger fish first.  Note the three guys in your example all went to LA.  Players have 29 other choices and sometimes the other choices are more attractive.  That's a fact of life, not a failing of the MBT.  Who doesn't want to win a ring with Lebron?

Maybe we should stop trying to be LA and do what Indy did the moment free agency opened with Brogdon or what Utah did the moment free agency opened with Bogdonovic or what Charlotte did the moment free agency opened with Hayward.  Make those guys Plan A.  Atlanta used $37 million in space last summer to get Gallinari AND Bogdonovic.  Do that rather than waiting around on a 1% chance Kawhi picks us.  We can debate who that is in 2021, but it is the team's job to know who would jump at the chance to be here and who might have us further down their list.  

I don't see a path to Collins.  My interest in him was at the TDL when you could hold his matching rights.  I see a huge issue with trying to work this out with Atlanta while other names are flying off the board (we know how that movie ends).  I'm also not sure we would be Collins' first choice.  I get why a Dallas-centric community would think playing next to Luka and KP is perfect for any player.  However, if I am his agent, my main job is to get the most I can get now and set him up for the next contract.  I'd much rather place him where he would be first or second fiddle rather than third.  That way he's got a much better shot at a five year 7-9 max money deal the next time.

A great example of this is Christian Wood.  We sent Detroit more than enough salary to match Wood and pretty clearly they preferred Wright over Ariza.  The rest of the deal with Houston wasn't hard to replicate.  My takeaway isn't that the MBT failed.  My takeaway is Wood saw a bigger role (and greater future riches) in Houston.  Crowder said the same thing about Phoenix.    

We can debate the specific names.  You don't like Monk, what about Norman Powell or DeRozan or Fournier or Duncan Robinson or Dinwiddie.  I don't think it will be hard to replace what THJ does.  Just because the team says they will be "aggressive" (which they say every year), it doesn't mean they are going to strictly look at Max guys.  What I'm advocating is making your target(s) guys that are realistic and getting that done at 5:01 like other teams in similar markets seem to be able to do.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - Branduil - 04-02-2021

(04-02-2021, 08:52 AM)DanSchwartzgan Wrote: I don't think the issue is how hard it is to get the middle class.  I think the issue is the middle class is always Plan B while we chase the bigger fish first.  Note the three guys in your example all went to LA.  Players have 29 other choices and sometimes the other choices are more attractive.  That's a fact of life, not a failing of the MBT.  Who doesn't want to win a ring with Lebron?

Maybe we should stop trying to be LA and do what Indy did the moment free agency opened with Brogdon or what Utah did the moment free agency opened with Bogdonovic or what Charlotte did the moment free agency opened with Hayward.  Make those guys Plan A.  Atlanta used $37 million in space last summer to get Gallinari AND Bogdonovic.  Do that rather than waiting around on a 1% chance Kawhi picks us.  We can debate who that is in 2021, but it is the team's job to know who would jump at the chance to be here and who might have us further down their list.  

I don't see a path to Collins.  My interest in him was at the TDL when you could hold his matching rights.  I see a huge issue with trying to work this out with Atlanta while other names are flying off the board (we know how that movie ends).  I'm also not sure we would be Collins' first choice.  I get why a Dallas-centric community would think playing next to Luka and KP is perfect for any player.  However, if I am his agent, my main job is to get the most I can get now and set him up for the next contract.  I'd much rather place him where he would be first or second fiddle rather than third.  That way he's got a much better shot at a five year 7-9 max money deal the next time.

A great example of this is Christian Wood.  We sent Detroit more than enough salary to match Wood and pretty clearly they preferred Wright over Ariza.  The rest of the deal with Houston wasn't hard to replicate.  My takeaway isn't that the MBT failed.  My takeaway is Wood saw a bigger role (and greater future riches) in Houston.  Crowder said the same thing about Phoenix.    

We can debate the specific names.  You don't like Monk, what about Norman Powell or DeRozan or Fournier or Duncan Robinson or Dinwiddie.  I don't think it will be hard to replace what THJ does.  Just because the team says they will be "aggressive" (which they say every year), it doesn't mean they are going to strictly look at Max guys.  What I'm advocating is making your target(s) guys that are realistic and getting that done at 5:01 like other teams in similar markets seem to be able to do.

In that case I think the logical offseason move would be to go after someone like Holmes and hope you can swing a trade for a guy like Brogdon later.


RE: ROSTER TALK: DAL with $22.7M - $34.4M in capspace this summer - StepBackJay - 04-02-2021

(04-02-2021, 08:52 AM)DanSchwartzgan Wrote: Maybe we should stop trying to be LA and do what Indy did the moment free agency opened with Brogdon or what Utah did the moment free agency opened with Bogdonovic or what Charlotte did the moment free agency opened with Hayward.  Make those guys Plan A.  Atlanta used $37 million in space last summer to get Gallinari AND Bogdonovic.  Do that rather than waiting around on a 1% chance Kawhi picks us.  We can debate who that is in 2021, but it is the team's job to know who would jump at the chance to be here and who might have us further down their list.  

I don't see a path to Collins.  My interest in him was at the TDL when you could hold his matching rights.  I see a huge issue with trying to work this out with Atlanta while other names are flying off the board (we know how that movie ends).  I'm also not sure we would be Collins' first choice.  I get why a Dallas-centric community would think playing next to Luka and KP is perfect for any player.  However, if I am his agent, my main job is to get the most I can get now and set him up for the next contract.  I'd much rather place him where he would be first or second fiddle rather than third.  That way he's got a much better shot at a five year 7-9 max money deal the next time.

A great example of this is Christian Wood.  We sent Detroit more than enough salary to match Wood and pretty clearly they preferred Wright over Ariza.  The rest of the deal with Houston wasn't hard to replicate.  My takeaway isn't that the MBT failed.  My takeaway is Wood saw a bigger role (and greater future riches) in Houston.  Crowder said the same thing about Phoenix.   

So ya I don't disagree with the approach of operating more like Indy, Utah or even Atlanta. 

I do see a path to Collins which is you need to outbid other suitors. Mavs may or may not succeed but I think that's their plan A.

For Christian Wood I just don't think that was ever going to happen with the roster which had. Mavs weren't going to sign him to a big deal even if it was a potential good asset management move and I don't think Wood would have signed here anyway without a guaranteed starting spot.

Crowder also got a guaranteed starting spot and probably more years than the Mavs were willing to give. He would have been a great fit and asset move had the Mavs signed him instead of WCS/Burke.

So I don't disagree with your approach at all. Mavs want to believe they are on the same tier as LA teams, Miami, etc but they are more like on the Atlanta, Chicago, Houston tier of destinations which is to say those don't really have much of an advantage over small market Indy or Utah when it comes to signing FAs. At that level its really ab the contract size more than anything else.